On Tuesday, 23 April
1985 the Coca-Cola company made a shocking announcement. They were
going to introduce “New Coke” on the company’s centenary
anniversary. The new drink would not only taste better being sweeter
than the century old formula, it was healthier, pandered to the whims
of vegetarians, was kosher and halal. This was everything
the old formula was not and everything pointed to the new drink being
an overwhelming success. Except it wasn’t. In fact, the new product
launch was a disaster.
![]() |
| image: courtesy of coca-cola |
So what was their mistake? It was not the market research. They had done an extensive one earlier on before as part of their bid to introduce a new Coke which was part of their secret project named “Project Kansas.” They had used samples, surveys, and focus groups and the result was an overwhelming preference for the new drink. However, they also discovered that about 10-12% of the people whom they surveyed were very angry at the very thought of New Coke. The small group exerted significant peer pressure on the rest so much that when the New Coke was later officially launched this group influenced the rest of the Coke market. This led to the eventual failure of the product line, which despite all efforts was later withdrawn even with all its “goodness.”
Parallels of the New
Coke can be drawn with Microsoft’s efforts with Windows 8 and
Ubuntu’s Unity desktop. Contrary to what has been said by some
so-called technology blogs, both initiatives were not pulled out of
the thin air and forced on unwitting users. They were both outcomes
of research.
Unity was a desktop
that had previously shipped as part of the Ubuntu Netbook Remix
flavor of the Ubuntu operating system for a while before it
supplanted GNOME to become Canonical’s default user interface on
the Ubuntu Desktop in Ubuntu 11.10. It is important to note that
Unity was, just like New Coke, a result of “secret research” in
computer user habits and an attempt to better serve the user based on
these habits. The result was a
backlash from a small portion of very vocal users who were mostly
made up of a minor group of so-called power users who felt alienated
and wanted things like the ability to move the Unity launcher from
the right to the left and lamented the fact that the Unity Desktop
was less customizable.
This small group of
people kicked up such as fuss, with posts like “Linux Torvalds uses
XFCE” and “Distrowatch shows Linux Mint is the most used Linux
Distro” and other words to that effect that seemed to imply that
the whole Ubuntu world was in an uproar and did not like the changes. This was in spite of
multiple surveys clearly showed that Unity was and still is the most
used Linux Desktop environment. There are still a lot of Unity
bashing posts out of there by people who have never even used Unity.
Not long after
Ubuntu introduced Unity as the default Desktop early in 2011, a
change whose implementation was delayed until 11.10, Microsoft made
a phased release of various versions of its Windows 8 operating
system. Its reception was way better than what Vista had received but
still it was a less than ideal reception. The operating system
was nothing but polarizing while a group of users warmly embraced the
radical changes a significant number of users were nonplussed by the
whole thing. Even though, Microsoft claimed that this was a result of
research on user habits and experiences and an attempt to solve them,
a lot of people were not convinced. Not even after a hasty “patch”
came in the form of Windows 8.1.
Although in the case
of Unity and Windows 8 there were a number of bugs at first, I
strangely feel there were more bugs in the former than in Windows 8.
At the beginning based on my experience, the operating systems had
evolved in a bid to solve perceived customer problems. These problems
had all been identified using some form of limited scope research and
usually in secret research projects.
The
problem was not in the inventions themselves but rather in how they
were adopted and used. Professor Elton Mayo a business theorist once
conducted a series of human experiments at Hawthorne Works at Illinois and came up with what
has been known ever since in business circles as the Hawthorne
effect.
To paraphrase it: it
does not matter how good a change is, as long as those people who are
affected by the change do not feel that there were properly consulted
in effecting the change they will in all likelihood reject it. The
converse is also true: people will accept any change no matter how
bad as long as they feel they were part of that decision.
In all the cases
above, those who felt aggrieved by the changes were nit-picking
because they felt they were not part of the decision to effect a
change that all affected them. People woke up one day and were told
they had to make do with New Coke, their Desktop world had been
upended and now they had to use Unity or the Start Screen or take the
hit the highway.
A small minority
aided by competitors and rivals like Pepsi for Coke; GNOME,KDE and
Linux Mint for Unity and Ubuntu and a host of various companies for
Windows seized on this opportunity to create the perfect storms as
they jostled to grab market share.
The aftermath
All three companies
reacted differently to these whirlwinds. Coca cola hurriedly
reintroduced the old Coke and renamed the New Coke, Coke II which
they pretty much ignored until they finally put it out of its misery
in 2009, decades after its introduction.
Mark Shuttleworth on
the other hand obstinately hung on to his dream in the face of
adversity and fierce criticism and eventually succeeded in winning
hearts in Ubuntu 12.04 LTS when most people finally embraced his
dream as the Unity project became more mature.
The folks at
Microsoft have been feeling a lot harried for a while now so much
they have flirted with different solutions like Windows 8.1 which was
not all that popular in solving some of the people’s demands before
finally coming up with Windows 10.
It is as much a revolution as it is about stymieing
some of the objections raised in Windows 8 from resurfacing. It aims
to do what Windows 7 did to Vista. They have also been more vocal
about the impending features and promoted the pre-release versions.
The lessons
While it is true
that a lot of lessons can be drawn from the Coca Cola, Unity and
Windows 8 stories such as not to hastily introduce products to the
market before ironing out the kinks, the major lesson is that
it is always important to involve the customer when developing New
Products no matter how big you are or risk pissing them off.
Your competitors,
the sharks that they are, will grab the opportunity to bury you as
well. Don’t just send a curtly worded email or SMS informing them
of a change that will shortly be implemented. Give them ample time to
absorb the intended change and its implications.
The first rule of
change; Don’t just flip the switch and hope for the best. It will
buy you a lot of goodwill to warn and consult people in the first
place. You will be surprised how many of your
customers will welcome the change even if it is an adverse one
because they feel involved.



No comments:
Post a Comment